Due to inactivity the KDGA forums have been locked. All past threads are still available. Please join us on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/groups/kansasdiscgolf!
2005 Doo Dah
IMO Smitty, you are correct on all of that! Good job.smitty wrote:Jon Holmes told me today that he was called for a foot fault, after making a good drive. Only one person made the call. He then said that they made him redrive? Wouldn't the first foot fault only be a warning, and he shouldn't have had to rethrow. He also said this person was busting his chops for 3 rounds. What the helk, they were on the third card in AMII.
He also told me Monster D was given a courtesy violation for kicking his bag and cussing. Also done without warning and was given 2 strokes. Is this correct? Courtesy violation is only a 1 stroke penalty and you still get a warning.
Did the same guy give the penalty to Monster D? Just wondering...Don
Maceman and I were the officials on the am flights. I know that I heard nothing about these calls. In the first case the call must be made within three seconds of the throw. If it is made by a member of the group it must be confirmed by a second member of the group (only an official is allowed to call it on their own and not as a member of the group). If the call was not confirmed by another player the call was not valid. If it was it would require a warning and a re-throw, no penalty. Subsequent valid stance violations in the same round would bring a one stroke penalty as well as a re-throw. If there was question about the validity of the call Jon was in his right to challenge the call and if an official was not handy to settle it then he could have made the second drive as requested on a provisional basis and play both discs, keeping score on each until an official ruling could be made.smitty wrote:Jon Holmes told me today that he was called for a foot fault, after making a good drive. Only one person made the call. He then said that they made him redrive? Wouldn't the first foot fault only be a warning, and he shouldn't have had to rethrow. He also said this person was busting his chops for 3 rounds. What the helk, they were on the third card in AMII.
He also told me Monster D was given a courtesy violation for kicking his bag and cussing. Also done without warning and was given 2 strokes. Is this correct? Courtesy violation is only a 1 stroke penalty and you still get a warning.
The second call, if it was made in the manner you noted, was clearly incorect. A courtesy violation can be called by anyone affected by the violation, in or out of the group, or an official. The first violation of the round results in a warning. Subsequent violations in the same round warrant a one stroke penalty. This call should have been noted on the card and brought to an officials attention for a final call.
You called it like you saw it .... not as it is .... nothing shady in all of this. I called it as it is ... as you confirm ... . it was a cheap shot.Sandman wrote:Okay dude let me put it like this..........
You think I took a cheap shot so what??? Thats why I put a IMO behind the post. CUZ ITS MY OPINION!!!
And the reason I posted what I posted was b/c it seems like every time someone posts tourney results they always put money amounts next to who got what. AFTER people on here started asking questions and wanted scores and PAYOUT posted somebody didnt do that so I thought it looked a little shady...........sorry if you or bobo took offense but I was just calling it like it is.
BTW dont come to hays cuz I'm sure you'll be disapopointed in the PAYOUT!!!
Should I make it to Hays someday (and I hope to next year) I'll be sure to bring some extra cash to give you for finishing out of the cash
Jer
-
SmoothDrawOS
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2004 1:38 pm
-
jump_putter
- Posts: 419
- Joined: Mon May 16, 2005 12:33 pm
- Location: hoping i'm outside 33'
-
Notorious ROG
- Posts: 206
- Joined: Tue Aug 03, 2004 8:53 am
- Location: OKC or WIC depends on day of week
ACDGC
First, thanks to all who attended, we hope to see you next year!
Second, this was our first B tier & I want to thank all the ACDGC members and local non-members who helped make it a SUCCESSFUL B tier event.
Finally, we will post the final report with PDGA next week, that is the time frame we have established. Until I can review the tournament information as Treasurer, Bob's hands are tied. We have not been able to get together. This year is a first for us as a formal club with officers, next Year we will have had the experience of running a Tourney as a BOD and hope to smooth things out a bit.
I appreciate the feedback both good & bad we have received, we will take the suggestions to heart next year.
Can we PLEASE drop the conspiracy theories, and TD bashing. If you have a legitimate question or concern feel free to PM or call me at 316 734 4831 thanks ROG.
Second, this was our first B tier & I want to thank all the ACDGC members and local non-members who helped make it a SUCCESSFUL B tier event.
Finally, we will post the final report with PDGA next week, that is the time frame we have established. Until I can review the tournament information as Treasurer, Bob's hands are tied. We have not been able to get together. This year is a first for us as a formal club with officers, next Year we will have had the experience of running a Tourney as a BOD and hope to smooth things out a bit.
I appreciate the feedback both good & bad we have received, we will take the suggestions to heart next year.
Can we PLEASE drop the conspiracy theories, and TD bashing. If you have a legitimate question or concern feel free to PM or call me at 316 734 4831 thanks ROG.
-
SmoothDrawOS
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2004 1:38 pm
-
SmoothDrawOS
- Posts: 184
- Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2004 1:38 pm